let’s talk bookish | quality & creativity vs. capitalism

Hello again, dear friends! I hope all is well with you and if it’s not then I hope brighter days head your way soon. I’m here today with a new post for Let’s Talk Bookish that I actually wasn’t planning on making. But then I had a second glance at the topic and had a good think and, well, it turns out that good think produced many Thoughts (who woulda thunk 😂). So, here I am, back at it again with another installment of Let’s Talk Bookish. Let’s get straight to it!
let’s talk bookish
Let’s Talk Bookish is a weekly bookish discussion meme created by Rukky at Eternity Books and now hosted by Aria at Book Nook Bits and Dini at dinipandareads. This week’s prompt is…
Reading has become increasingly more “popular” due to platforms like booktok and bookstagram, which tend to promote certain types of books. It has also given rise to the “trope only” marketing trend. Do you think the hype that’s been created on these platforms has impacted the quality of books that are published these days? Do you think it’s impacting only certain genres or do you notice it across all genres? How do you think this will impact book quality and publishing in the years to come (i.e. is it just a phase or will it continue)?
are social media & “trope marketing” to blame?
Honestly, this will be the shorter section despite the fact that I’m going to make a bold claim: I don’t think bookish social media is 100% to blame for any kind of watering down of literature that we may currently be seeing. Since the early 2000s, literary marketing has always been tied to social media. I say this because people forget that prior to the rise of booktok there was the rise of bookstagram and before that the rise of booktube and before that the rise of book blogs. Look, if we want to go back even further, we can even make an argument for newspapers and magazines being early forms of “social media” and als0 include literature reviews from those mediums in the mix. Since the dawn of human existence, there has always been art, and so long as humans have been able to express themselves, there has likely always been art criticism as well and, further, since the dawn of societies forming, that also means that people have tried to use self-expression to influence others. And, you know what? I’m gonna go out on a limb and say that, in this case (in the case of the quality of literature and art), social influence spouting from self-expression of individual opinion isn’t necessarily the root of the issue here. Certainly, social media makes us more aware of the wealth and volume of individuals opinions. But at the end of the day, we still are choosing where to turn our attention, whether or not that attention has been influenced by social media algorithm curation.
As for trope marketing, that has always been a thing, even prior to social media giants like TikTok, partially because tropes have always existed. Even prior to being more aware of literary “tropes,” we were aware of “archetypes” and familiar “plot structures” in folklore, fairy tales, and myths. You could ask your parent to tell you a rags-to-riches story involving royalty and they’d have several choices of folktales, fairy tales, and myths to tell you. So, I don’t necessarily think trope marketing is an issue, largely because it’s always been a thing, we’re just more aware of it due to the volume of social media content using it.
So, with that all said, let’s get down to the bottom of what I think is really causing a drop in quality of what’s being published nowadays…
the “LATE-STAGE capitalism” of it all
Call me a communist (you’d be correct), but I think a lot of what we’re seeing with the watering down of the standards of all art—including literature, cinema, TV, music, and other areas—comes down to the inherent conflict between the very nature of art and of being an artist and the inherently restrictive and quality-degrading requirements of capitalism. There have been many anthropological and historical studies that demonstrate that prior to the rise of capitalism, people had a lot more free time, even during busy times like harvest seasons in feudal societies. People used that downtime to fulfill their regular needs such as cooking, cleaning, clothing themselves, etc., but because they had enough extra time to do these tasks, they also fused these tasks with making art. So, for example, sewing clothing turned into using embroidery to embellish clothing, creating folk art out of a basic necessity. This shows anthropologists (and the rest of us, if we’re paying attention lol) a couple of things. First off, it shows that when humans have the time, they inevitably create art even if that art also fulfils other survival needs (and basically, this shows that art is also a survival need). Second off, this show that art thrives in environments where individuals have the resources, freedom, time, and energy to create it. In a capitalistic society, though, the only people who consistently have all of those things (i.e. resources, freedom, time, and energy) available to them are, you guessed it, the ultra-wealthy. Because the rest of us are typically on a five days a week work schedule which requires that we contribute so much labor in all forms (physical labor, mental labor, and even emotional labor) that often we are left completely drained during our one-to-two-day break. So, you can see that in this way, capitalism is massively in conflict with what is required to create art at all, let alone to create good art.
This isn’t the end of the issue, though.
Capitalism is also inherently in conflict with creativity and artistic freedom in another major way, that being that the goal of any capitalistic company is not to create a quality product. The goal of a capitalistic company is first, foremost, and only to make money. That is all. If that means foregoing quality, then companies will do just that. We see this reflected in areas like fashion, where companies (including “sustainable” companies existing within the paradigm of capitalism) churn out masses of low quality garments which are sewn in sweathouses by workers who don’t make a living wage, but such garments are essentially created to degrade easily and quickly because that way the company can get you to buy the garment twice—the first time because you want it, and the second time because the garment has degraded quickly and now you want a replacement.
Okay, so that’s fashion, but how does this “profit over all else” ethos affect the publishing industry? Well, it’s effect is threefold in the publishing industry:
- Publishing companies want to pick up more of what’s currently making them money, so they invest in a lot of similar manuscripts, regardless of whether or not those stories are actually ready for publication
- Publishers then pump out a lot of these similar stories, essentially flooding the market with a wealth of choice—but in reality that choice boils down to a gazillion copies of very similar stories
- Because publishing companies are first and foremost, companies, they want to create as much product and generate the highest possible revenue while also keeping their production expenses as low as possible. This leads to them cutting corners and cutting back on things like, ya know, paying editors and paying low level employees who provide the “grunt work” that is ultimately necessary to keep the company on its feet
And what does this leave us with? Well, it leaves us with a heap of low quality literature. But hey, so long as you still have hope that quality literature is out there, at least you’re still willing to buy from those publishers, so they not only sold you shit literature, but now they also have the guarantee that you’ll come back again for a second round.
So, what is the solution? Honestly, pals, the only solution is socialism and eventual communism 😂 But that’s more of a long game solution. What can we do right now to at least mitigate the problem? I don’t think there’s really an easy, quick fix to this one. That said, finding ways to support authors outside of the publishing machine scheme and advocating for strong unions within the publishing industry are probably good ways to start getting the ball rolling.
spill the beans, friends!Do you think literature has declined in quality lately? If so, what do you think has caused that decline? Do you think social media/social media marketing has played a role? Do you think capitalism has played a role? Do you have any ideas for solutions?
change the world with me!Before anything: FREE PALESTINE!!! 🍉 For over half a century now, the Israeli government has been enacting a genocide against the Palestinian people. This is more than something that started on October 7, 2023. It’s not complicated. It’s genocide. And it’s important that we witness, raise our voices, protest, and fight against it in any way possible. Below are a list of resources to help educate yourself on Palestine, as well as to donate to aid the Palestinian people. In addition, I’ve added some Palestinian influencers and journalists you can follow to learn more from and who keep track of what’s going on. Peace to all and keep fighting the good fight!

2 Comments